| Orchard Park | Lake Shore | |
|---|---|---|
| vs Eden/North Collins | W 12-5 | W 11-9 |
| vs Frontier | W 15-14 | L 4-10 |
| vs Grand Island | W 12-11 | W 12-5 |
| vs Hamburg | W 13-12 | L 11-12 |
| vs Lancaster | L 4-15 | L 7-19 |
| vs Niagara Wheatfield/Niagara Falls | W 11-6 | L 7-19 |
| vs West Seneca West | W 14-4 | W 12-7 |
| vs Williamsville East | W 18-10 | W 13-8 |
| vs Williamsville South | W 15-11 | L 8-12 |
