| New Paltz | Middletown | |
|---|---|---|
| vs Goshen | W 13-10 | L 7-12 |
| vs Highland/Marlboro | L 2-17 | L 2-12 |
| vs O'Neill | L 7-11 | L 6-10 |
| vs Our Lady of Lourdes | W 10-5 | L 5-6 |
| vs Pine Bush | L 4-9 | L 9-10 |
| vs Red Hook-Pine Plains | L 8-13 | L 6-11 |
| vs Rondout Valley | L 8-14 | L 8-13 |
| vs Washingtonville | W 12-11 | L 7-8 |
